You, Me & Tuscany, Anna (Halle Bailey) who's struggling to make ends meet travels from NYC to Tuscany to squat at the villa of a man, Matteo (Lorenzo de Moor) she had briefly met at a bar. She leads his family including his mother, Gabriella (Isabella Ferrari), to believe that they got engaged. Meanwhile, she flirts with Matteo's brother, Michael (Regé-Jean Page), a winemaker. Director Kat Coiro and screenwriter Ryan Engle have made a clunky, uninspired and cheesy romcom with only a few laughs and a miscast Halle Bailey, but it's harmless, breezy and uplifting with lots of great scenery. The first thirty minutes of exposition feel dull and silly as Anna meets Matteo's family who own a restaurant. Once Matteo inevitably arrives, the film becomes somewhat more engaging and even manages to occasionally find its footing. Many scenes veer into sitcom or even parody territory with barely any moments that are true-to-life and with too many implausibilities. The characters seem like caricatures, some of them only there to provide comic relief.
      Moreover, the ending can be seen from a mile away, and the film doesn't offer any surprises with the exception of Matteo's grandmother (Stefania Casini) giving Anna the blessing to "tap that ass!" while referring to Michael. What does Michael even see in Anna? What does she see in him beyond their physical attraction? They lack chemistry together, but that could have something to do with Halle Bailey's poor acting skills and the shallow screenplay. You, Me & Tuscany would be the inferior B-movie in a double feature with Under the Tuscan Sun, which gets a cringe-inducing reference before the credits roll. Be sure to stay through the credits for bloopers which are only mildly funny. At a running time of 1 hour and 45 minutes, You, Me & Tuscany opens nationwide via Universal Pictures.
Number of times I checked my watch: 3